Jolly's

Jolly's is the go-to liquor store on Stock Island, stocking a solid range of beer, wine, and spirits that'll cover just about anything you're looking for. It's the spot on this island, which means prices run a bit higher than the mainland — but when it's the only game around, you work with what you've got. Worth noting, it's earned a top-three nod for best liquor store in the Keys, so the selection clearly speaks for itself.