Aigaio Pelagos

You'll find this family-run Greek taverna sitting right on the waterfront of Vathy's picturesque natural harbor, where you can watch fishing boats come and go while enjoying traditional dishes. The menu covers all your bases with fresh fish, meat dishes, and hearty starters, plus they're surprisingly accommodating with vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options. It's the kind of authentic local spot where you can linger over a long Greek meal with your feet practically in the water.