Roostica Pizzeria

Roostica brings authentic Neapolitan wood-fired pizza to Key West, staying true to Naples-style tradition rather than going the typical tourist-trap route. You'll find hand-crafted pizzas alongside pastas and local favorites, all with a laid-back island vibe that feels genuinely Italian rather than theme-park Italian. Located on MacDonald Ave, they're open daily from 11am to 10pm — worth a stop when you're craving something real.