Pizzeria La Tartaruga

Sitting right on the bay of San Gregorio in Capo d'Orlando, La Tartaruga serves up wood-fired pizza alongside a broader Italian menu in a spot that locals clearly keep coming back to. The waterfront setting gives the whole meal a relaxed, unhurried feel. With 249 reviews on Tripadvisor, it's well-trafficked enough to be reliable, even if opinions are mixed — worth a stop for the location alone.