Grill Šime

Tucked away on the northern, quieter side of Prvić Šepurine island, Grill Šime is rated one of the top spots in the area for a reason — locals and regulars keep coming back for the grilled fish, which people consistently call the highlight. The vibe is warm and welcoming, and it feels like the kind of place that hasn't tried to be anything other than what it is: honest, unpretentious Croatian food done well. It's ranked #7 of 10 restaurants in Prvić Šepurine, but given the small size of the island, that puts it firmly in the must-try category.