Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen

Yellowfin Bar & Kitchen on Peninsular Ave serves up seafood pulled straight from their marina, so you're getting about as fresh as it gets in Key West. The menu leans into local Florida flavors — think whole fried yellowtail snapper, almond-crusted grouper, and char-grilled filet — and they'll even cook your own catch if you bring one in. It's a laid-back spot that takes its food seriously without being stuffy about it.